Backups are no longer optional

by Chris Foley on January 22, 2009



“It’s time we had a little talk.  It’s about something uncomfortable, but we can’t keep pretending that you don’t have a problem.  I don’t know how to say this, and I’m kind of embarrassed, so I’m just going to come out and say it.  How recent is your latest backup?”

Of course, I jest, but in many cases, and with a goodly amount of people we work with, this very sort of intervention is needed.

Ask yourself the following questions: How well do you trust your backup solution?  How often do you use your backup software?  Do you verify your backups?

As Pausha pointed out to me earlier today, my most amusing occupational war stories all involve backups (or the lack of them.)  It’s no laughing matter to lose all of your important data, or even worse, to lose a client’s important data, which opens you up to all manner of professional difficulty, including possible liability.  Traditionally, the burned hand teaches best, and I’ve found this old adage to be absolutely true.  Hopefully, you can take some wisdom from this article, and learn from someone else’s burned hands.

For the sake of simplicity, I’m going to divide this article into two portions.  The first will cover your basic home backup needs, and the second will address the more specific needs of creative professionals, such as musicians, videographers, editors, photographers, designers, etc.

First, a story; no, a confession.  In 2005, we were moving Pausha (web designer) from her obsolete G4 Lampshade iMac (I still miss that design!) to a newer G5 tower.  Unfortunately for us at the time, we were still backing up onto CDs.  I backed up all of her project data, and then wiped her iMac’s hard drive to prepare it for sale to a friend.  
I discovered the next day while preparing her user account on her new computer, that many (um… almost all) of the files on the backup CDs were not copied correctly.  That’s right, I lost most of her project files, and her personal design work files.  Our most recent prior backup was a month or two old, and we were able to recover a small amount of her data, but all of the projects she was currently working on were gone.  The obvious result is that she had to build 2 websites back up from scratch, and redesign a few complicated images which had already been approved.  My carelessness caused her more than a full 40-hour’s labor, and frankly, compared to what we’ve seen in the past few years with other clients, she got off easy!

I learned two extremely valuable lessons from this experience, not counting the amazing quality of forgiveness exhibited by my wife.  The first lesson was to verify my backups instead of simply assuming that I am, in fact safe.  The second lesson was to create a backup solution that was solid, reliable, and easy for Pausha to execute on her own.

The simple truth for most people is that unless their backup process is very easy, they cannot be counted upon to do it with regularity.

time-machine-finder

Consumers take note.
With OSX 10.5 Leopard, Apple has delivered Time Machine, which is a robust and automated backup software which leaves us with very little in the way of excuses.  If you’ve got an older version of OSX installed, and do not have Time Machine, there are many good backup programs available for you, but none of them offer Time Machine’s ease of use.  With Time Machine, once configured, all you have to do is take a look its logo in the menu bar, and watch for error messages.  What’s even more important is that Time Machine makes it easier than ever to recover lost files than any other backup program I have ever used.  What’s the point of running daily backups if you have to battle to recover files in the event you need to?

We can talk about hard drive manufacturers until the cows come home.  There are many brands of external hard drives out there, and I’ve used many of them, and I’ve experienced mechanical failure with several of them.  I have had the best luck with LaCie drives, and I work regularly with video professionals who swear by LaCie drives and will use no other brands.  To be absolutely clear, I have also had my share of LaCie drives die on me, but in my own experience, LaCie offers excellent products with the lowest fail-rate I’ve seen.

What to buy?  What size drive?
It really depends on how you use your computer.  Do you have a desktop Mac, or do you use a portable MacBook or MacBook Pro?  How big is the internal hard drive of your computer?

You’ll want to get a drive that has at least 1.5 times the capacity of your computer’s drive.  If you have an iMac with a 200GB hard drive in it, get a 300GB backup drive.  Or get a 500GB backup drive if you think you may outgrow your computer’s internal drive in the near future.

I recommend the following three drives for most people.
Here’s one for MacBook owners, the LaCie Little Disk.  Check it out HERE.

hd_littledisk2-5_usb

MacBook Pro owners might consider this, LaCie Rugged Drive.  Check it out HERE.

hd_rugged_1

For Desktops I’d recommend this drive.  LaCie D2 Quadra.  Check it out HERE.

hd_d2quadranext

I’m actually using this for my MacBook Pro, but it’s mostly because my MBP lives on a stand on my desk, and it’s really easy for me to remember to plug in.  I used to backup to a portable drive, but I would forget to pull the portable drive out of my bag and plug it in.

(oh, by the way, these drives only work if you plug them in to your computer regularly.  I actually had someone tell me that they didn’t realize that.  No, your data will not backup through the computer’s mitochondrial cell walls, you actually have to participate a little bit.)

Time Machine will run a backup for you every hour as long as your drive is plugged in and mounted.  If you don’t have your drive plugged in all the time, as I do, you should attach the drive and let Time Machine do its thing at least once a day.

That’s it.  For anyone who’s running an older version of OSX, give me a call, or email and we can talk about what backup software options are available to you.


—————————-

For the Pros
Creative professionals have a larger backup burden, especially folks in the video world.  First, creative professionals need to be backing up their own application and user data just as the normal home user does, but we’re also responsible for client footage and data, as well as our own creative work.

For anyone who shoots and edits a lot of video or does a lot of audio recording, and has not heard me rant about this before:  you should NEVER write video or audio (in quantity) to your internal system hard drive.  Ever.  Doing so will cause your system hard drive to fragment faster than anything else in the world.  And if you lose your system drive from fragmentation, not only are you out of the game until you can have it repaired, you also run the risk of losing that important data.

Creative Professionals should work to a drive other than our system drives.  If you have a tower, you should have a separate designated work drive installed.  If you’re using an iMac or a portable, you should be working directly onto an external drive.  And NOT the drive you’ve got your system backup on.  Duh.  The whole point of this entire exercise is redundancy.

Here’s another story for you.  I worked with a videographer last week who has a G5 Tower with a separate work drive which contained all of his client’s video footage on it.  He recently came home to discover that his computer had been hit with a huge power surge (I’ll write about surge protectors later) and both of his internal hard drives had failed.  NO backup.  He has an external backup drive, but he hadn’t plugged it in and run a backup in months.  What to do?  Since his computer was miraculously not destroyed, we put 2 new hard drives in, installed the system and all of his applications, and sent him home with essentially a brand-new computer.  But all of that lost footage?   Gone.  Forever.  I don’t want to be on the phone when the clients find out.

I do video.  I do audio.  I do photography.  Here’s what I use.

  • My Backup drive.  This backs up my system, my applications, music, home movies, photos.

  • My Project Drive is a 2TB LaCie Raid disk.  This drive contains two 1TB  hard drives.  I write my projects to one of the 1TB drives, and then it automatically backs itself up onto its other 1TB drive.  If I find myself needing more than the 1TB, I can simply purchase a couple of raw drives with larger capacity and replace them.  The cost of blank drives has gone so low that backing up huge volumes is no longer cost prohibitive.  Check this drive out HERE.  If you’re working with a lot of audio, video, or photographs, you should seriously consider getting one for yourself.

2bigtriple_3

Both drives are plugged into my MacBook Pro almost all of the time, except for when I take my MBP to meetings or retire to the patio with it.  I obviously don’t drag these external drives with me to the couch.  When I return my computer to my desk, I plug the drives back in, and the backups begin.  I almost don’t have to think about it anymore, and when I accidentally throw away a video clip, or delete a Mail folder I can quickly recover it, and lose only the 90 seconds or so that it takes for Time Machine to restore that file.

Bottom Line
It’s all going digital.  Video cameras are currently the best-selling consumer electronic on the market.  We’re putting more photos and home movies on our computer than ever before.  We’re downloading Gigabytes of music from the internet.  We’re digitizing our paper records, using Quicken to manage our finances.  It’s time to give serious consideration to your backup routine.  The burnt hand is the best teacher, but there are some things I’m willing to let others learn the hard way.

If you’ve got any questions or comments, please feel free to leave them in the comments section of this post.

Thanks for reading!

 

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

Speak Your Mind!

{ 10 comments }

1 Rain January 24, 2009 at 10:58 am

Thanks, Chris! Very helpful, as I’ve been debating switching from Retrospect to Time Machine. It’s going to be Time Machine for me.

XO,
Rain

2 Greg Gehr January 29, 2009 at 12:27 am

I use time machine to back up to a external HD at home (I am using Western Digital HDs at work and home), but it does not feel like that can be the only backup method. I have too much invested in audio and video, as well as personal and business files, to not have an offsite backup too. (in case the house burns down, or somebody steals the equip., whatever)

I am currently testing Crashplan backup software, which has a FREE version for personal use, up to 10 machines. You and a friend, (both with decent internet connections, say DSL or better), can back up over internet to each other (you each buy an external HD, install it on your FRIENDS computer, and backup over internet to your remote HD), limits on bandwidth and scheduling of backup is available, it is encrypted, continuous, incremental, and complementary with Time Machine (and cross platform). So far, it is slow but steady, no noticeable hit in performance on net or mac, and testing of selective restores has been fine.

If my testing continues to be positive, I plan on using the commercial version at work, in ADDITION to Retrospect, as a secondary line of backup. (Time machine not option for work as 60% of our work macs are Tiger or Panther). Just got a 4TB Drobo plus already have an OWC drive raid box, I will put one in each field office for work, and back up each location to the other during night if Crashplan ends up being our choice for secondary offsite backup.

Crashplan will also do local backup over LAN and/or to local volume, but I am going to keep Retrospect running at work, and Time Machine at home, at least for foreseeable future. I just don’t think you can have too much backup these days, as the stories above illustrate!

The Crashplan folks also sell storage on their servers, but it sounds expensive, not for me.

You followed me on Twitter, (@GregGehr) which lead me here. Thanks for a great article.

3 Chris January 29, 2009 at 12:21 pm

Hi Everybody, I forgot to mention this in the article, but I’m with a client right now, who has reminded me, through inaction, that you must remember to turn the backup hard drive ON, before Time Machine will work properly.

So here it is. Make sure your drive is powered on. Okay. There we go.

Thanks
CHris

4 Tim Moore February 3, 2009 at 10:38 am

Hey Chris,

Great article. I’ve read it twice now. Very informative.

I have two questions specific to Final Cut Pro:

(1) When using HD Cameras recording to P2 cards, what is the best way to store the Source Media? Should I import the Source Media (from the P2 cards) to a mirrored external Raid and then use the same Raid as my Scratch? Or should the Source Media be kept on a separate external drive?

(2) Where should I keep the FCP/Compressor/DVD Studio Output files? Should they also be kept on the Scratch drive? Or with my FCP files on my internal hard drive?

Thanks!

5 Chris Foley February 3, 2009 at 11:19 pm

Hi Tim
Thanks for taking the time to ask, these are really great questions.

You ask what should you do, and my question back is well, what can you AFFORD to do?

(1)
The best practice is separate your scratch from your source, but in most cases we don’t do that. That would require having lots and lots of storage around, which gets expensive fast. It’s okay to use the same drive for your Capture as for your Scratch. For that matter, you can even put your Exports on the same drive, AS LONG AS this drive is getting backed up, after EVERY session, every day, whether it’s via mirrored RAID or some automated software backing up onto another external drive.

(2)
Answer (1) sort of answers this, although I will mention that I do not store ANY work files, be them Capture, Scratch, or Export files on my internal System Drive. I keep my System Drive clean. Apps only. I do also have program resources (such as LiveType and Soundtrack content) on my System Drive. This is not so much of a bus hog, but that’s even more of a reason to be writing to an external work drive in the first place.

The LaCie RAID drive I mention in the article is a great solution if you’re looking to have an external work drive which creates its own redundancy.

KEEP IN MIND: this does NOT handle the disaster issue: what should happen if your home or office burns down or is burgled? Double redundancy is not covered in this issue, but the absolute best practice is to create a backup of your backup which leaves the office with you every night.

Also, I use the LaCie RAID drive mentioned above for my work drive, which is great, because it’s mirrored. HOWEVER, I use YET ANOTHER LaCie external drive to backup my internal system drive via Time Machine.

In this way, any one drive I have can burn out, and all I have to do is grab another raw drive, install it, run a restore, and I’m good to go.

6 Chris Foley March 7, 2009 at 11:38 pm

Yes Tim, you’re now ready to start using that drive. Let me know how it works out, and how quickly you fill it up!

7 Tim Moore February 25, 2009 at 11:13 pm

Amazon.com is currently out of the 2TB Lacie RAID you recommend above. What is the next best place to buy from?

8 Chris Foley February 25, 2009 at 11:51 pm

Try CDW. Little bit more expensive than Amazon, but cheaper still than getting it direct from LaCie.
Here you go: http://www.cdw.com/shop/products/default.aspx?EDC=1306007

9 Tim Moore March 6, 2009 at 3:19 pm

Hey Chris,

I finally have the LaCie 2Big Quadra 2TB drive you recommended. I changed the RAID setting to “Safe” Mode (RAID1), and then partitioned the drive for one volume, which I’ve called “Moore Work.” Am I ready to start using that volume as my Final Cut Pro Scratch Disk?

FYI, my Lacie Backup drive (for my personal files) has been great. Time Machine is so much easier than burning my files to CD.

Thanks.

10 Tim Moore February 5, 2009 at 3:18 pm

Chris,

You rock! Thank you so much for your feedback above. I now know what to go buy.

Tim

Previous post:

Next post: